The moral failing of insurance that pays ransom regularly, makes no attempt not to, affirmatively disengages leaders and funds terrorism should be obvious, but many argue with me, stating that insurers are doing the best they can, have incomplete data, or that they are improving.
Unfortunately, they’re not. There have been a few small measures taken, mostly just in terms of wording changes. Not a dime has been invested in enforcement or compliance management.
To show how negligent these insurance companies have been, it’s important to take a look at the applications they have for cyber insurance. These applications represent all that these companies have, in terms of policy controls. It’s abundantly clear that no adult with any idea how any of this works wrote these. There is never any other enforcement. Even large clients do not receive independent assessments or audits. These “requirements” are not generally enforceable, do not create a call to action and, just plain won’t ever work. Money will continue to be lost until even the most minimal efforts to do otherwise are made.
Cyber insurance is considered a loss center (for some reason) and for this reason it gets zero investment and the underwriters who end up on this line are typically the lowest achievers. That’s truly the opposite of what is needed here.
These applications seem to be current, although some have not been updated in years. I do not think it is at all unreasonable to say that those who were responsible for writing the loss controls, for an insurance that paid extortion, to foreign hostile parties, should face some kind of criminal charges. This is not normal. This is not okay. It should not be normalized to have such clueless people, when professionals are avaliable.
Check out this PDF to get an idea of just how bad this situation is.
BREAKDOWN OF CYBER INSURANCE APPLICATIONS
HSB Total Cyber Insurance Application
AIG’S CYBER UNDERWRITING APPLICATION
Travelers CyberRisk Applications and Forms
Chubb Cyber And Privacy Insurance
Beazley Cyber Application
The Hartford CyberChoice Premier Application
FailSafe Cyber / Information Risk Supplement Application
